Lifting the veil of incorporation under common law and statute chrispas nyombi school of law, university of essex, colchester, uk abstract purpose the paper examines case law and statutory provisions related to lifting the corporate veil. In considering whether the corporate form has been used in such a way as to justify the lifting of the corporate veil, the court stated that the correct test in relation to groups of companies was whether the company had been used as a mere facade concealing the true. The corporation is entitled to a minimum of equitable funds. A legal concept that separates the personality of a corporation from the personalities of its shareholders, and protects them from being personally liable for the companys debts and other obligations.
Principle of lifting the corporate veil legal service india. In conway vs ratiu 2006 1 all er 571, allud lj speaks of the readiness of courts, regardless of the precise issue involved, to draw back the corporate veil to do justice when common sense and reality demand it. The aim of the paper is to explore recent case law in order to determine whether courts have moved. Principle of lifting the corporate veil there is often talk about how a company is a person in eyes of law. Usually a corporation is treated as a separate legal person, which is solely responsible for the debts it incurs and the sole beneficiary of the credit it is owed. Aug 27, 2019 the most common way of lifting the corporate veil in company law one can come across involves close corporations every corporation must follow the laws of the state of incorporation. Jan 07, 2015 the corporate veil may be lifted where the statute itself contemplates lifting the veil or fraud or improper conduct is intended to be prevented. Lifting the veil doctrine exists as a check on the principle that, in general, investor shareholders should not be held liable for the debts of their corporation beyond. A guide to the corporate veil and when it can be pierced 2019 update registering a company means that as an owner, youll be protected under the corporate veil.
In this respects, the court will get through the corporate shell and apply the guideline of what is known as lifting or piercing the corporate veil. Piercing the corporate veil the alter ego doctrine under federal common law. Lifting of corporate veil of company under company law. Sep 20, 2019 under what circumstances should the court lift the corporate veil or should not lift the corporate veil. However, there are circumstances where this can be overridden. Lifting of the corporate veil doctrine in india lawescort. Under florida law, a party wishing to pierce the corporate veil must. The corporate veil can be lifted by the courts if its presence would create a substantial injustice. Introduction the lifting of corporate veil doctrine remains one of the most difficult areas of hong kong company law. Lifting of the corporate veil means disregarding the corporate personality and looking behind the real person who are in the control of the company. For simplicity, this article will use piercing of the corporate veil to encompass both.
Taxat times tax legislations warrant the lifting of the corporate veil. Among instances when corporate veil is lifted are as follows. Lifting of corporate veil under company law an analysis. In the united kingdom, the corporate veil doctrine is generally called lifting of the corporate veil as opposed to piercing of the corporate veil. Piercing the corporate veil wex us law lii legal information.
Introduction when carrying on business, seeking an appropriate corporate structure which accommodates to the needs of the intended business and lifting the corporate veil uk law. Piercing the corporate veil refers to a situation in which courts put aside limited liability and hold a corporations shareholders or directors personally liable for the corporations actions or debts. Reasons for lifting the veil of incorporation studocu. The lifting of corporate veil doctrine in hong kong. A guide to the corporate veil and when it can be pierced. Piercing the corporate veil or lifting the corporate veil is a legal decision to treat the rights or duties of a corporation as the rights or liabilities of its shareholders. The three justifications for piercing the corporate veil. Today, shareholders can be held liable in the case of an interference destroying the corporation. This doctrine emphasizes that a company has a separate entity from its. Lifting of corporate veil with reference to leading cases.
Jun 19, 2018 lifting the corporate veil english company law. The company, in the contemplation of law, is a person distinct from the shareholders. Lifting or piercing of corporate veil circumstances in. The five most common ways to pierce the corporate veil and.
Piercing the corporate veil or lifting the corporate veil is a legal decision to treat the rights or. Lifting of corporate veil part 1 by bhanu pratap youtube. The issue came up for discussion in the case of adams v. In adeyemi v lan and baker nig ltd, the court held that there is nothing sacrosanct about the veil of incorporation. A company is a juristic person, but in reality it is a group of person who are the beneficial owners of the property of the corporate body. While the law varies by state, generally courts have a strong presumption against. On this pretext, lifting of the corporate veil can be brought under 2 heads, namely. Besides companies act, 20, certain provisions of incometax act and foreign exchange regulation act, 1973 also enables the lifting of corporate veil. To offer a full account of the exceptions to the corporate personality doctrine, this. Lifting the corporate veil legal definition of lifting the. Oct 12, 2016 however, there are also certain decisions which require shareholder approval, either under the law or according to the companys shareholders agreement. And while by the fiction of law an organization is an unmistakable element, yet truly it is an association of people who are in reality the beneficial proprietors of all the corporate property. There is no common, unifying principle, which underlies the occasional decision of. Revised 16 march 20 the aim of the paper is to explore recent case law in order to determine whether.
Lifting or piercing the veil is corporate laws most widely used doctrine to decide when a shareholder or shareholders will be held liable for obligations of the corporation. The common law notion of piercing the corporate veil is applied to protect the interests of a companys creditors. A corporation under company law or corporate law is specifically referred to as a legal person as a subject of rights and duties that is capable of owning real property, entering into contracts, and having the ability to sue and be sued in its own name. The essay analyses and scrutinises under which circumstances the corporate veil can be disregarded in the uk. Under what circumstances should the court lift the.
It is neither necessary nor desirable to enumerate the classes of cases where lifting the veil is permissible, since that must necessarily depend on the relevant statutory or other provisions, the. Piercing or lifting the veil is corporate law s most widely used doctrine to decide when a shareholder or shareholders will be held liable for obligations of the corporation. The companies act, 1956 the companies act 1956, itself provides for circumstances, when corporate veil will be lifted and the individual members or directors will be made liable for certain transactions. Revised 16 march 20 the aim of the paper is to explore recent case law in order to determine whether courts have moved.
Lifting the veil of incorporation under common law and. Under the australian corporate law or the company law, a corporation is referred specifically as a legal person. Where a court determines that a companys business was not conducted in. Whilst there is a general reluctance to lift the corporate veil, there is a body of case law where the courts have considered doing so. Lifting the veil occurs where the courts or law disregard the corporate personality of the company in deserving circumstances. Cases and articles have been used to set out the main principles in which the law is based. Lifting of the corporate veil in uk and cyprus under. Piercing the corporate veil is the legal jargon used to describe an action.
The concept lifting the veil of incorporation essay. Thus, a bold attempt has been made to provide a clear and general compass for all jurisdictions as to when courts will pierce the corporate veil to guide judges, legislatures, corporate managers, law students etc. Lifting the corporate veil academike lawctopus for law. Under what circumstances should the court lift the corporate. Lifting of corporate veil academike for law students. Australian corporation law lifting the corporate veil. Lifting of corporate veil of company under company law law.
Under the corporate personality doctrine, there are case law and statutory provisions to lift the corporate veil and to hold the shareholders personally. The aim of the paper is to explore recent case law in order to determine whether courts have moved away from an overly restrictive approach when dealing with cases relating to the corporate personality. It is given mandate to provide various kinds of information such as minutes of meetings, number of directors, list of objects for what the company is formed and others. Reinforcement of the separate entity principle was recently made in fdb financial services ltd v adesola 4. Doctrine law lifting the corporate veil as such is not given in the text of indian company law but could be inferred from number of provisions. The veil shall be lifted to prevent the avoidance of recognition by the eyes of equity. Aug, 2019 the essay analyses and scrutinises under which circumstances the corporate veil can be disregarded in the uk. While the law varies by state, generally courts have a strong presumption against piercing the corporate veil. Lifting the veil of incorporation wmh law corporation. An anatomy of the grounds of lifting the corporate veil. There are cases where the courts need to understand if the company is an enemy or friend. The paper examines case law and statutory provisions related to lifting the corporate veil. There is a dearth of overarching guiding principles for a body of largely incoherent case law. In a number of circumstances, the court will pierce the corporate veil or will.
Jun 15, 2016 in conway vs ratiu 2006 1 all er 571, allud lj speaks of the readiness of courts, regardless of the precise issue involved, to draw back the corporate veil to do justice when common sense and reality demand it. The corporate veil is vital for the legitimate use of the corporate structure and the protection of shareholders and directors and thus, by its very existence, promotes the playing field for. In times of war the court is prepared to lift the corporate veil and determine the nature of shareholding as it did in the daimler case where germen shareholders held the shares of an english company during the time of world war 1. The first point to be dealt with in prest was whether english law recognises the concept of piercing the corporate veil at all. In such cases, the courts adopt the test of control. Lifting the corporate veil 1 english company law youtube.
Lifting the veil of incorporation under common law and statute lifting the veil of incorporation under common law and statute chrispas nyombi 20140204 00. Under what circumstances should the court lift the corporate veil or should not lift the corporate veil. Lifting or piercing the veil is corporate law s most widely used doctrine to decide when a shareholder or shareholders will be held liable for obligations of the corporation. Piercing the corporate veil under the new companies act. This doctrine is called lifting the veil of incorporation. For example, veil piercing may be done where the corporation is the mere alterego of its shareholders, where the corporation is undercapitalized, where there is a failure to observe corporate formalities, where the corporate form is. Feb 04, 2014 lifting the veil of incorporation under common law and statute chrispas nyombi 20140204 00. To offer a full account of the exceptions to the corporate personality doctrine, this paper also. The principle of corporate veil as a concept got evolved post salomon under common law. These exceptional circumstances can be referred to lifting or piercing the corporate veil. Purpose the paper examines case law and statutory provisions related to lifting the corporate veil. Piercing the corporate veil in the canadian common law courts. One of the most common grounds for the lifting of corporate veils, in cases wherein the shareholders of the company are indulging in fraudulent acts.
Lord sumption stated that there was a range of circumstances in which the law. It continues to be one of the most litigated and most discussed doctrines in all of corporate law. Keywords corporate personality, company law, lifting the corporate veil. Revised 16 march 20 the aim of the paper is to explore recent case law in.
It is present in the corporate law of many countries, including the uk, the usa, france, and germany. It may hold the stockholders personally liable for the firms obligations under the legal concept of lifting the corporate veil. Piercing or lifting the veil is corporate laws most widely used doctrine to decide when a shareholder or shareholders will be held liable for obligations of the corporation. Nutritek heard argument that there is in fact no principle of law which allows a court to disregard the separate legal personality of a company. Lifting the veil can be used to impose liability upon the shareholders or for other purposes, such as ascertaining appropriate jurisdiction. As such, you will likely have some involvement and responsibility in the path the company takes regardless of whether you are a director or a shareholder of a company. German corporate law developed a number of theories in the early 1920s for lifting the corporate veil on the basis of domination by a parent company over a subsidiary. Lifting the veil of incorporation under common law. The phrase piercing the corporate veil was described in a 1973 case as now fashionable. Development of civil law led to development of a list of exceptions to the principle that legal entity is separate and independent from its founders.
Though it can be traced to common law, since indian laws are heavily reliant on common law, this doctrine has also been adopted and applied in toto. In other words, where a fraudulent and dishonest use is made of the legal entity, the individuals concerned will not be allowed to take shelter behind the corporate personality. To lift the corporate veil or look behind it, on the other hand, should mean to have regard to the shareholding in a company for some legal purpose. In many instances this proviso also aims to combat fraud, which is in the public interest. He submitted that if the conditions are satisfied for lifting of the corporate veil as observed in the aforesaid decision of.
Lifting of corporate veil under the companies act ipleaders. Artificial entities that are created by state statute, and that are treated much like individuals under the law, having legally enforceable rights, the ability to acquire debt and to pay out profits, the ability to hold and transfer property, the ability to enter into contracts, the requirement to pay taxes, and. Generally, the situations where a court may lift the corporate veil fall into two categories. Common law countries usually uphold this principle of separate personhood, but in exceptional situations may pierce or lift the corporate veil.
What is lifting of corporate veil in company law malescu. As explained above, while the shareholders limited liability resulting from the separation principle under turkish law, the turkish courts of. However, the courts have not always applied the separate legal entity principle as the salomon case. Veil piercing is most common in close corporations. Section 218 of the 2008 companies act extends liability, while s 209 codifies the doctrine of piercing the corporate veil. Salomon is the judicial authority that enforces the legal personality of corporate entity especially when it has been incorporated. Horne 1933 company being used as a mean to avoid prior contractual obligation and abuse of cooperate vehicle dhn case established. The most common way of lifting the corporate veil in company law one can come across involves close corporations every corporation must follow the laws of the state of incorporation.
The law on when a court may disregard this principle by lifting the corporate veil and regarding the company as a mere agent or puppet of its controlling shareholder or parent corporation follows no consistent principle. Lifting of corporate veil academike lawctopus for law. Lifting the veil of incorporation under common law and statute. The doctrine is very much applicable in indian law. The lifting of the corporate veil of a company to determine its enemy character falls within the latter i. This study focuses on the lifting of the corporate veil in uk and in cyprus, as the latter has been applied as an exception to the principle of the separate legal personality of the companies in common law countries. Statutory provisions on lifting the corporate veil have also been provided. The courts take the stance that they are bound by the principle laid down within salomon whereby a company is considered an entity separate to its members. This is the process used to look behind the corporate facade and identify the true nature of a transaction.
Development of the lifting of the corporate law veil doctrine in india pierce independent entity corporate law companies act shareholders creditors management. Common law countries usually uphold this principle of. This means the corporation is regarded as a subject who has rights and has capability of entering into contracts, owning property, can be sued and has the ability to sue in its own name. The doctrine of lifting the corporate veil means ignoring the corporate nature of the body of individuals incorporated as a company.
515 539 16 873 1133 336 826 1197 1180 508 1160 1241 978 655 412 1066 684 1482 129 1423 652 1126 88 1207 1193 373 419 923 461 368 1083 435 1003 1083 315 1475 924 54